PBPA 2014 coral reef assessment in a nutshell

Overview of the public seminar & 2014 PBPA reef health results in a nutshell

Suzanne & AchsahOn Wednesday 25th February 2015 we launched the results of the 2014 coral reef assessment of the Portland Bight Protected Area (PBPA). The Jamaica Environment Trust (JET) hosted the public seminar at the Knutsford Court Hotel, Kingston, Jamaica. Attendees included representatives from the Centre for Marine Sciences (the University of the West Indies), Caribbean Coastal Area Management Foundation (C-CAM) the National Environment and Planning Agency (NEPA), Urban Development Corporation (UDC), Environmental Foundation of Jamaica (EFJ), University of Technology, Jamaica (UTECH), among others.

Virtual divePhotographs can say a thousand words so what better way to start the seminar with a ‘virtual dive’ slide show comprising many photographs that we had taken during the surveys. This was followed by presentations on the coral and reef health (Suzanne Palmer) and an excellent  discussion of the fish data by Achsah Mitchell (MPhil, primary project fish surveyor). After providing the national context to the PBPA reef health data and associated recommendations we heard from Mr Charles Moodie (Old Harbour Fishing Beach). Mr Moodie has been our invaluable field support and boatman throughout the project. His personal comments and thoughts on the project provided some local context to the scientific data and proved to be fascinating and insightful.

What did we find?

  • Reasonable live coral cover when compared regionally. Highly variable across individual coral reefs and often dominated by opportunistic coral species (e.g. Porites astreoides). Reefs with higher coral cover also have large colonies of framework building species (e.g. Orbicella complex). Overall reasonably healthy corals with levels of recent partial coral mortality not considered to be stressful.
  • Highly variable macroalgae cover (PBPA overall average fleshy macroalgae 19.4%; PBPA overall average calcareous macroalgae 12.9%).
  • Very low relief coral reefs – low structural complexity largely to due to dominance of low-lying opportunistic species and rubble-dominated substrate. Reefs do have small areas with large coral outcrops and larger framework building coral species.
  • The long spined sea urchin (Diadema sp.) occurs in reasonable densities, however more are needed for effective grazing given the amount of macroalgae.
  • Very low fish biomass but very high fish density. The PBPA reef fish are dominated by large shoals of small fish (parrotfishes and surgeonfishes, also grunt), a large proportion of which are juvenile and not of reproductive age. Large sized fish are typically absent reflecting fishing pressures.
Drawing comparisons to other coral reefs is often complicated, largely due to differences in how the data was collected, terminology used, and the variation between reef systems.
Blue tangs
Blue tangs, Pigeon Island (Suzanne Palmer)

Regional: We have compared all our data from the PBPA to a regional database1 of surveys that use the same methodology. Overall the coral reefs are in reasonable condition and near to regional averages (coral and benthos). The exceptions are for fish biomass and fish size which are extremely low across PBPA reefs – there are a lot of fish (very high fish density) but they are generally all small. Whilst not the healthiest in the Caribbean they fair reasonably and are clearly far from the worst.


Orbicella annularis
Orbicella annularis, Pigeon Island

National: The PBPA reefs are typically patch to small fore reefs that grow within shallow waters (<11m, average 5.6m) with variable water clarity, and therefore differ to the extensive fringing coral reefs of the north coast in Jamaica. This is in part due to differences in geology and geography of the continental shelf around Jamaica – the PBPA reefs are located on the south coast where the continental shelf is wide. The PBPA reefs occur as patches or small fore reefs around cays and islands, whereas on the north coast the continental shelf is narrow and in places the reefs form deep reef walls. This results in differences, for example the types of reef, depth ranges, water clarity, and oceanographic currents. Differences aside, we compared the Porltand Bight reefs to 2013 NEPA2 survey data from selected marine parks around Jamaica (that used a modified Reef Check methodology, we used AGRRA) and found that they are comparable and in places fair better than some at the national level. The PBPA coral reefs are clearly important habitats to Jamaica and therefore it is crucial that they are protected and managed.

It is recommended that focus should be on: (1)    Maintaining and restoring coral reef habitats, and (2)    Restoring fish populations to ensure sustainable fisheries.

Click here for available resources. Full scientific report coming soon.

This project was made possible by a Waitt Foundation Rapid Ocean Conservation Grant to Dr Suzanne Palmer.
Contributions & Acknowledgments:
Scientific reef survey team: Dr Suzanne Palmer, Achsah Mitchell, Kimani Kitson-Walters, Ivana Kenny; Project planning & facilitation: Centre for Marine Sciences, UWI: Marcia Ford, Professor Dale Webber; Boat and field support: Charles Moodie (Old Harbour Fishing Beach); Dive survey volunteers: Loureene Jones, Monique Curtis, Kayla Blake, Sean Green, Yannique Ewers; Field support and dive gear hire: Port Royal Marine Laboratory; Scientific data analyses: Dr. Suzanne Palmer; Dr Judith Lang (AGRRA); Kenneth Marks (AGRRA); Scientific interpretation: Dr. Suzanne Palmer; Dr Judith Lang (AGRRA); Salt River trip & project discussions: C-CAM: Brandon Hay; Scientific communication: Dr Suzanne Palmer; Dr Judith Lang; Dr Patricia Kramer; Achsah Mitchell; Jamaica Environment Trust; Underwater photography: Ivana Kenny, Dr Suzanne Palmer, Dr Michael Burn.
1AGRRA regional database 2011-2014: Jamaica (Pedro Bank), the Bahamas, Belize, Columbia, Honduras, Navassa, Mexico, St. Kitts/Nevis.
2NEPA (2014) Coral Reefs of Jamaica, An Evaluation of Ecosystem Health: 2013. NEPA, 15pp.

Updates from the field: coral reefs in the PBPA, Jamaica

Are development decisions within a marine protected area being made with heads entirely above water?

Since my last post we have managed to get out to survey the coral reefs in the Portland Bight Protected Area during what has been a very windy August. I am currently analysing all the data collected so far and look forward to sharing our findings on the PBPA coral reefs with the public and scientific community.

So what do we know about the coral reefs in the PBPA? NEPA have been carrying out ReefCheck surveys since 2004 on a number of the reefs in the PBPA and C-CAM also conduct various surveys, however, the last time that the PBPA was collectively surveyed, assessed and reported was ~10 years ago by the Jamaica Coral Reef Monitoring Network under the Centre for Marine Sciences/CDDC and facilitated by C-CAM. In light of the controversial and elusive development plans for a transhipment port and logistics hub at the Goat Islands in the Portland Bight Protected Area I have the following scientific questions which we intend to address:

What are the current characteristics and conditions of the PBPA reefs? Which, and how many, of the threatened and endangered coral, fish or other marine species live in the PBPA? What is at risk from the controversial proposed development of a transshipment hub in the area? Are development decisions within a marine protected area being made with heads entirely above water?

It is now September and we have surveyed 9 different sites across the PBPA using the AGRRA survey methodology, and are currently working up some of the preliminary results – watch this space! We are still surveying and wishing for some more calm weather! Since the first blog post we have surveyed Tern Cay, Pigeon Island and Pigican Shoal.

Tern Cay

We have tried to survey Tern Cay many a time and had to abandon our plans due to rough seas – but this time we caught lucky and were able to spend a few hours underwater completing surveys of the benthos, fish and coral. Tern Cay is located ~1.5km south of Manatee Bay with fairly strong currents and is a great spot for sightings of turtles, rays, and nurse sharks.  To our delight we came across spotted eagle rays, turtles, and a 3-m long nurse shark and  juvenile – we were only able to catch a shot of the juvenile as were busy with heads down along our survey lines – better luck next time! Nurse sharks are slow-moving bottom-dwellers and are, for the most part, harmless to humans. Getting a bad rap in the media we need to remember the importance of sharks in our oceans and for coral reef ecosystems.

Tern Cay survey team, front row from left: Achsah Mitchell, Suzanne Palmer, Yannique Ewers; back row from left: Kimani Kitson-Walters, Ivana Kenny.
Extensive blankets of seaweed (Sargassum) offshore from Hellshire beach (Photo credit: Ivana Kenny)

Prior to surveying Tern Cay a week of stormy weather had churned up the shallow waters along the coastline producing these expanses of seaweed – not so great for the boat engines! The bad weather has delayed surveying here in Jamaica, however, we may be thankful for the strong winds or storms to cool off the waters and prevent coral bleaching. Recent reports (and USGS news) from the south Florida Keys indicate they haven’t been so lucky with extensive bleaching of massive and branching corals.

Juvenile nurse shark – Tern Cay (Photo credit: Ivana Kenny)


Pigeon Island

At last we have got to survey the most exposed part of the reef and what a treat – large shoals of fish hanging in the currents and manta rays on the move! Our fish surveyors were kept busy tallying away with all the large schools of fish across the reef! Coral and benthic surveyors focused on the area dominated by Orbicella annularis colonies. A couple of weeks ago the NOAA announced the addition of 20 new coral species added to the US Endangered Species Act list, 5 of which are Caribbean coral species and include Orbicella annularis.

In the sheltered back reef lagoon we also came across patches of Acropora cervicornis. The two branching species (Acropora palmata and Acropora cervicornis), formerly the most dominant reef-building Caribbean species, have been on the Endangered Species Act list since 2006. Our observations and data collection on threatened coral species in the PBPA is important – determining the location, density and current health of these threatened species will provide the basis for future monitoring, together with potential restoration and mitigation plans.

Clump of staghorn coral (Acropora cervicornis), Pigeon Island (Photo credit: Ivana Kenny)

Data is also being collected on the fish communities of all the reefs in the PBPA – fish that are important for the reef ecology and commercially important fish. Fish surveyors have been collecting data on all fish species across the reefs to determine fish density, size classes, and estimates of total biomass of individual fish species.

Over the last couple of months Caribbean coral reefs have hit the world headlines with the latest release from the International Coral Reef Initiative: Status and Trends of Caribbean Coral Reefs: 1970-2012 and a hard-hitting message that “Caribbean coral reefs will be lost within 20 years without protection”. They highlight overfishing of herbivores (particularly parrotfish) as a key problem that needs managing in addition to enforcing legislation and regulations to protect coral reefs from overfishing and coastal development. Not long after the release of the ICRI report and associated media was the announcement from the small island of Barbuda that the Barbuda Council had signed new laws for new ocean management regulations (coastal zoning, fisheries management and establishing a network of marine sanctuaries). Barbuda have become the 1st Caribbean island to prohibit the catching of important reef herbivores (parrotfish and sea urchins). Inspiring work from the Waitt Institute and the Barbuda Blue Halo project.

Shoal of Tomtate grunts (Haemulon aurolineatum), Pigeon Island (Photo credit: Ivana Kenny)


Pigican Shoal

This is a rather strange name don’t you think? Well even Mr Moodie our boat guy who knows the PBPA like the back of his hand did not know of the name. It turns out that previous surveyors have created the name based on where it is located – in between Pigeon Island and Big Pelican Cay = Pigican! Anyway, despite only being down to the absolute core survey team we were blessed with calm seas at this exposed shoal and spent the whole day getting all the surveys completed between us – go team!

Watch out – data, photos and more news coming soon!


Special thanks to the survey teams, particularly Kimani Kitson-Walters, Achsah Mitchell and Ivana Kenny for dedication and persevering with the early morning starts, and to Ivana for the excellent photos! Particular thanks to Dr Judith Lang and Dr Kenneth Marks who are providing scientific input, review and verification of all the data we are collecting.  Thank-you to Mr Charles Moodie, our excellent boatman and field support from Old Harbor. Our thanks are extended to Hugh Small and the Port Royal Marine Laboratory team for all their efforts in facilitating the trips. Thank-you to the Jamaica Environment Trust for disseminating the work we are doing. This project was made possible by the Waitt Foundation Rapid Ocean Conservation Grants Program.


AGRRA Reef surveys in the Portland Bight Protected Area

Updates & photos from 2014 coral reef surveys in the PBPA funded by a Waitt Foundation ROC Grant

The plan to establish a transhipment port within the largest protected area in Jamaica is controversial, however, it is unclear which marine ecosystems could be threatened or lost by the potential development. This project aims to provide a scientific assessment of the status and condition of coral reefs within the Portland Bight Protected Area which is funded by the Waitt Foundation 2014 Rapid Ocean Conservation Grants Program.

Hover over photos for caption, click on photos to enlarge. Photos by Ivana Kenny.

The main reef sites can be seen in the map below. Across each reef we have multiple survey sites in order to fully represent the coral reef zones and subtypes. We are using the AGRRA method (http://www.agrra.org/) to determine coral reef condition. This includes taking detailed measurements of the corals species (e.g. size and condition), quantifying the main algal types, and determining the abundance and size of key fish species.

Image from Google Earth (click to enlarge)


Our first surveys: Wreck Reef

Earlier in June (08.06.14) we made it out to Wreck Reef for the 1st official AGRRA survey of the project. Heading out from Port Royal Marine Laboratory, Mark Golding and Terrence dropped us right on the reef.  The team headed off in their pairs to collect data with one pair performing fish surveys, another coral surveys, and a third benthic surveys. The weather had been blowing for a good few days so visibility was not great. Check out the photos below of the Staghorn coral (Acropora cervicornis) and also the Boulder star coral (Montastraea annularis).  The Staghorn coral is an endangered species within the Caribbean region (see: http://www.nmfs.noaa.gov/pr/species/invertebrates/staghorncoral.htm) and listed on the IUCN Red List of Endangered species http://www.iucnredlist.org/details/133381/0.

We had hoped to head out to Tern Cay but the weather was against us so we headed back to the marine lab and started data entry fueled by granola bars and bags of peanuts!


Weekend in Salt River – Pigeon Island and Big Pelican Cay

On Friday (13.06.14) evening we arrived at C-CAM’s base on the Gun Site in Salt River and were welcomed by Brandon Hay, CCAM’s Scientific Officer and the PBPA Fish Sanctuaries Manager. Brandon told us that the winds had been blowing strong and unfortunately they continued to blow throughout the night. 4am we were on the dock setting up our gear ready for an early start out to Pigeon Island. No time to Waitt for the weather! Joined by Mr Charles Moodie from Old Harbor we headed out to Pigeon Island. The following day we headed out from Old Harbor on fishing canoes to Big Pelican Cay, again the weather was not on our side so we carried out surveys across the sheltered back reef.


Best weather so far – revisiting Big Pelican Cay!

After so many rough days and cancellations I was pleased that we had a successful survey day on Sunday (29.06.14). We were on the water at 6am heading out from Old Harbor to Big Pelican Cay with Mr Charles Moodie and his friend on their fishing canoes. The reasonable weather allowed us to do surveys on the exposed shallow forereef (Big Pelican Cay East) and to the west of the cay (Big Pelican Cay West).

After refuelling with Bulla and water we headed off to Big Pelican West a narrow shallow spur where we came across numerous colonies of the Elkhorn coral (Acropora palmata). In places there were over 10 Elkhorn coral colonies within a square area of 10 metres – not a particularly common sight in Jamaica. The Elkhorn coral was formerly one of the most dominant species found within shallow parts of Caribbean reefs (~1-5m water depth) providing a structural framework for invertebrates and fish, however, since the 1980’s there has been a reported loss of 90-95% of this species due to a multitude of factors including coral disease (see http://www.nmfs.noaa.gov/pr/species/invertebrates/elkhorncoral.htm). The species is listed as Endangered under the US Endangered Species Act and is currently listed as Critically Endangered on the IUCN Red list of Threatened Species (http://www.iucnredlist.org/details/133006/0).

Over the next few weeks we’ll be out surveying whenever we have the weather windows. Look out for our next blog post to hear more about what we are finding.

Great job team, fingers crossed for good weather next weekend so we can get back to Pigeon Island!


Special thanks to the continued commitment and efforts of the survey teams, including Ivana Kenny for the excellent photos! Particular thanks to Dr Judith Lang for her constant support and guidance, not to mention providing a wealth of on-hand remote scientific expertise. Thank-you to Mr Charles Moodie and friend at Old Harbor who are our excellent boatmen and field support. Our thanks are extended to Hugh Small and the Port Royal Marine Laboratory team for all their efforts in facilitating the trips, and to Brandon Hay for helping to organise our Salt River trip. Thank-you to the Jamaican Environment Trust for disseminating the work we are doing which was made possible by the Waitt Foundation Rapid Ocean Conservation Grants Program.